H
TO: Zoning Board of Appeals
FROM: Howard Lindqvist, Senior Plans Examiner, Permits and Zoning
RE: Application 22-0871 / Appeal V-22-0871-A, Cinder Hill. Request to continue the hearing and to read a written answer into the record.
CC: Office of Caped Affairs; 311, Batch 22-0871-H; Case File V-22-0871
It is Sunday night and I am at the counter, because the appeal was docketed Friday, the hearing is on the 14th, and I would rather read thirty signatures on a Sunday than on a Wednesday.
For completeness, the appeal runs to thirty one pages. Thirty are signature pages, one signature each, and the pages are numbered by hand in the upper right corner, and I recognize the numerals, because they are the same numerals that were on the letter Mrs. Okafor sent the department in 2019 about the first emitter, which the department answered, and which she thanked us for in writing. The thirty first page is the letter, and it is one page, and it is the only page in the appeal that anyone needed to write.
I have read the letter four times. It does not ask that the apparatus be removed. It does not allege a violation of the code, and it does not contest the setback, which is 411 feet against a requirement of 250 (Zoning 14.3.2), or the height, which is 12 feet against a limit of 18 (Zoning 14.3.4). It asks that the neighborhood be told what the apparatus is and what it does. The thirty signatures are signatures on that question. I would only note, for the record, that an appeal which asks a question is not an appeal which states a ground, and that the Board may hear it however the Board pleases, and I say so as the examiner and not as the Board.
I wonder whether the Board would consider a continuance to the December calendar, and three things within it. First, that the applicant be permitted to file a written answer to the question, in plain language, not more than four pages, with one diagram, no drawings stamped and no engineering required, at his own expense. Second, that the answer be mailed to every signatory at the address on the signature page, by the department, so that no neighbor has to ask twice. Third, that any signatory be permitted to withdraw without prejudice and without cost, and that the fee, which is forty dollars, be refunded to anyone who does.
On the nuisance measure, the examiner took three readings at the porch of 40 Cinder Hill Terrace at approximately 19:15 on three evenings: 54.8, 54.8, and 55.1 in wind, against a night limit at the nearest lot line of 55.0. I recommend approval with the condition the applicant has already offered in writing, that the apparatus not be operated between 10 p.m. and 7 a.m., and with one further condition I would ask the Board to consider, that the apparatus in standby not exceed 52 decibels at the nearest lot line, which is 2.8 decibels below my three readings and which a shroud on the mast would accomplish without moving the mast or the pad. The applicant has not been asked about the shroud. If the Board permits, I will ask him, and I believe he will say yes, because he has said yes to every question this department has put to him across four applications, including the one about the fence, which he did not have to answer and answered anyway, in a paragraph, with a diagram.
It would be a kindness to the department if the answer and the question could be in the same room in December, since the department has the room, and since the hum is a refrigerator, and since a person is entitled to be told what is humming at the end of her street.
Howard Lindqvist, Senior Plans Examiner, Permits and Zoning. A permit is a promise.
H. Lindqvist, Plans Examiner. A permit is a promise.