A
The clock on the shelf stopped in March, and I wound it once, to see. It declined. So we have an arrangement now; I dust it, it stays stopped, and neither of us mentions the hour. Nan says a clock that has decided is not a broken clock. I have begun asking its opinion on other things.
A. the G. (retired)
F
Frank: Our hall clock quit in '79 and Dad never laid a hand on it again.
Fanny: '81, and he wound it every Sunday regardless, he just stopped setting it.
Frank: Don't ask it anything else, Aldous. It has already told you.
A
Then I shall stop asking, Frank; your father wound his Sundays and it answered anyway.
F
Frank: Then it answered him and not you. Dad's clock RAN.
Fanny: It ran because he wound it Sundays, which isn't the same as it having an opinion, and it quit for good the year the key went missing.
Frank: Your clock, Aldous. Wind it or don't.
A
Then the key is the whole of it, Fanny. A clock that runs while the key is turning is obeying the hand, not forming a view; yours quit the moment nobody could ask it any more. Mine was wound and had nothing to say. Frank, I shall leave it. It has already given me its answer, and it was a short one.
F
Frank: A clock with nothing to say has said ENOUGH.
Fanny: It said enough because he asked it twice, Frank, the winding was the second asking.
A
Fanny has it. The winding was the asking, and I asked twice; a clock may be pardoned for thinking the matter settled.
F
Frank: It answered him the FIRST time, which is the only asking that counts.